Best Garden Tractors For 2015 – Is a Garden Tractor right for you!
What is the best garden tractor? What makes a Garden Tractor?
Update: March 3, 2015
Although it is a term used quite often to describe a riding lawn mower, a garden tractor is actually designed to do more than just mow your lawn. Garden tractors are designed to mow your lawn and pull ground engaging equipment like a moldboard plow, box scraper, disk and tiller. They usually have 22 inch or larger rear tires that give the tractor the clearance needed to work in tilled soil. They also have heavy-duty transmissions designed to deliver horsepower to the rear wheels. The transmissions in these tractors can handle years of mowing steep slopes and some even have traction control or 4 wheel drive that help you go up and down slopes.
Garden tractors are easy to recognize from regular lawn tractors. The rear of the tractor frame slopes up.
This allows you to install a sleeve hitch for those ground engaging tasks. The estate model garden tractors have extra features like power steering, and hydraulics. Garden tractor prices start around $2900 for a 2014 Craftsman G5500 and well over $7000 for some of the estate models like the Simplicity Prestige series.
What makes Garden Tractors different from lawn tractors? Hint: It’s all about the transmission and wheels.
Is a Garden Tractor right for you?
If you primarily mow a large 2 to 5 acre lawn and once in a while grade your driveway, disk up a garden and haul 1000 lb loads of dirt or firewood a garden tractor is a good choice for you. The garden tractors you are most familiar with are a little more expensive than a lawn tractor with the same deck size but they also have larger tires and a heavier transmission. They will handle hills and rough lawns better than a residential zero-turn. The new Craftsman G5500 will turn almost as tight as a zero-turn and there is no learning curve to using it.
If your slopes are greater than 15% consider a tractor with traction control or differential lock. Snapper, Simplicity, Husqvarna and John Deere all have models with differential lock but they are higher priced.
If you want to do a lot of ground engaging work, have steep slopes, mow lawn and snow removal the John Deere X500 series is a really good choice.
Not Covered In This Review – LGT and Compact Tractors: In the last few years some manufactures like Husqvarna, Craftsman and Cub Cadet have started using the LGT designation. This is just a marketing term they are using to make you think you are getting a garden tractor without spending the extra money. LGT (light garden tractors) are designed to mow large areas of lawn comfortably but not designed to dig up your garden. The Husqvarna LGT26K54 sold at Lowes is a typical example. The lawn tractor uses a garden tractor frame but a lawn tractor transmission, Tuff Torq K46. This tractor has 22 inch tires. The transmission is too light for ground engaging tasks even though the rear frame will accept a sleeve hitch designed for ground engaging tasks. If the retailer is asking less than $2600 for a “Garden Tractor” you can be sure it does not have the heavy-duty garden tractor transmission. The Cub Cadet LGT 1054 and Craftsman G5100 Model 20401 are more examples of a lawn tractor with large wheels. The John Deere D170 is similar but Deere has wisely chosen to call it what it really is…a lawn tractor.
Many of the garden tractors 30 years ago were also capable of using a bucket loader and powering tillers. With the introduction of the compact tractor by Kubota, today’s garden tractors have changed and are no longer capable of that task. If you are interested in moving dirt, manure or digging in the ground compact tractors are the way to go. Contact your local rural lifestyle dealer for a free quote on a compact tractor.
I Heard a Shaft Drive Is What I Want.
Back in the 70’s most of the garden tractors used horizontal shaft engines connected to a transmission and an automotive style rear end. While these were bullet proof tractors they were horrible to drive. They turned about as sharp as your extended bed pickup and the engines alone weighed more than your current lawn tractor. They could pull a disk, plow or drag and a few of them had rudimentary mowing decks at best. The first lawn tractor that featured a drive shaft was the 1963 International Cub Cadet. International Harvestor (IH) did such a great job promoting the “drive shaft is better” that even today many customers come into lawn and garden dealer insisting they must have a shaft drive lawn tractor. The only lawn or garden tractor still made with a drive shaft is the Cub Cadet 2000 series – now manufactured by MTD. Today the Cub Cadet 2000 series is not better, it is just different from the rest of the group.
Today’s garden tractors use vertical shaft engines and high horsepower v-belts to drive the transmission.
“There wasn’t nigh as many as there was a while ago.”
40 years ago there were more than 100 different manufactures of garden tractors. Today there are very few tractors and only 4 manufactures. Everyone else has left this market segment and either makes a lawn tractor primarily for mowing lawns or compact tractor capable of doing much more than a garden tractor ever could.
Here is a list of the current garden tractors: I will update this as new ones arrive for 2015
My Review: This is the least expensive garden tractor available for 2015 with a hydrostatic transmission. It is one of the best for dependability and is just a good, basic garden tractor. (The Craftsman GT5500 is only around $200 more and has more features.) It has the best reinforced 54 inch cutting deck, the new Kohler 7000 motor and 16 inch turning radius. My Opinion: This Husqvarna built tractor has been around with various names on it since 2005. If you have big, open areas to mow. If your lawn is typically full of gopher mounds, mole runs and other “features” that keep it from being picture perfect this is a great rugged tractor. If you just want a tough, “old” garden tractor to mow your lawn, drag a DR box blade down your driveway, haul firewood, feed or dirt in your dump cart this is one of the best choices for you.
Brand: Craftsman Year: 2014-2015 Model: G5500 Item Number: 20403 Manufacture: Husqvarna Engine Brand: Briggs & Stratton HP: 24 Deck: 54 Transmission: Heavy Duty Hydrostatic Speed: 7.5 Street Price: 2999 or less MSRP: 3499 Where To Buy: Sears Craftsman 24HP 54″ Complete Start Turn Tight Garden Tractor – Non CA 16″ X 6.5″ – 8″ My Review:Craftsman 24HP 54″ Complete Start Turn Tight Garden Tractor My Opinion: This is the garden tractor that everyone else tries to compete against in the $3000 price range. It has been slowly evolving since the 1970’s and continues to be one of the best values for anyone that wants a heavy-duty mowing machine that will also pull stuff. It is the fastest garden tractor and was flying around your yard long before Jimmy Johnson put his name on the “Fast Tractor.” No it does not have traction control or power steering or hydraulics. But for the average backyard food plot, 300 foot driveway or 2-4 acre lawn this is one tractor that can do the job for a cost that is half of the other “better” garden tractors. With the addition of the 6 inch Turn Tight steering this tractor is a great alternative to a residential zero-turn. It will maneuver almost as well and does not have the learning curve associated with using a zero-turn for the first time. If you need traction control and a fabricated deck the Husqvarna GT52XLS is the alternate choice for this model.
Brand: Craftsman Year: 2014 Model: G7400 Item Number: 98645 Manufacture: Husqvarna Engine Brand: Kohler HP: 26 Deck: 54 Transmission: Heavy Duty Hydrostatic Speed: 7.5 Street Price: 2999 MSRP: 3499 Where To Buy: Sears Sears Online Exclusive My Review: To Come My Opinion: This is same Garden Tractor as the red Craftsman G5500 with three differences. A Kohler motor, a piece of pipe around the front of the deck (reinforced deck) and the new Craftsman and EZ Blade change
Year: 2011-2014 Model: GT48XLS(i)/GT54LS(i) Item Number: GT48XLS/GT54LS Manufacture: Husqvarna Engine Brand: B&S HP: 27 Deck: 48 fabricated/54 stamped Transmission: K66 Speed: 5.5 Street Price: MSRP:3199 Where To Buy:Dealer Locator My Review: I have not written a stand alone review of this tractor yet. My Opinion: If you don’t want a 54 inch deck this is one of the best value GT’s available. The John Deere X500 series is better and the Briggs/Simplicity Prestige is more expensive but the only real advantage they have is the ability to mount the tractor mounted Berco rear tiller.All things considered the GT48XLS is the great choice if you have hills. With the larger tires the tractor is only 2 inches longer and 1 inch higher than a lawn tractor so getting a “bigger” tractor is not an issue. The real advantage is the transmission. The differential lock trans on the GT48XLS compares to machines costing twice as much from Deere and Simplicity. If the wheels start to slip on your hill just press on the foot switch and it locks both rear wheels to give you twice the traction. (Always try to mow up and down slopes) I like the deck on this tractor. It is heavier than a stamped deck and is reinforced around the bottom edge so you can bang into things and not wreck the deck. It also has a good mulching kit available.
Year: 2011-2013 Model: GT52XLS Item Number: GT52XLS Manufacture: Husqvarna Engine Brand: Kawasaki HP: 24 Deck: 52 Transmission: Tuff Torq Speed: 7.8 Street Price: 3299 MSRP: 3299 Where To Buy:Dealer Locator My Review: I have not written a stand alone review of this tractor yet. My Opinion: This is an interesting tractor. It has an 8 mph “fast tractor” transmission and a welded deck all for 1 to 4 thousand less than other garden tractors with those features. Husqvarna states it has a heavy-duty frame and a well reviewed Kawasaki motor. It does not have a diff lock. Note: it is only sold at dealer stores.
Note: Husqvarna has the GTH24K54 but for 2014 they are listing it as a Yard Tractor.
Year: 2011-2013 Model: Conquest Item Number: 2691128 Manufacture: B&S Engine Brand: B&S HP: 27 Pro Deck: 52 Transmission: 2WD K66 Speed: 7.2 Street Price: 6499 MSRP: 8099 Where To Buy: See you local dealer My Review: I have not written a stand alone review of this tractor yet. My Opinion: The Conquest is a really nice mower. Heavy frame, automotive grade steering and little features like rubber cushions to keep the hood from rattling. Like the Craftsman GT-series this garden tractor has been a work in progress for many years. Craftsman made improvements to the tractor but kept the cost the same. Simplicity on the other hand not only made improvements but kept adding features that increased the functionality. Today it sports features like dedicated cruise control, automatic traction control, differential lock, single hand deck removal and even power steering on some models. 4WD is even an option. If you want a high-end tractor that will probably last as long as your roof check this mower out.
The biggest difference between this garden tractor and all the rest though is the deck. This deck is a ground hugging deck with a full-length rear roller. With the other garden tractors the cutting height is controlled by a lever on the tractor and the tractor tires set the height. If one tire is low the deck will cut low on that side. With the Simplicity the height is controlled by the gauge wheels on the deck and the height is independent of what the tractor is doing. This method gives you a very even cut that is always consistent. The full length rear roller gives you the striping that you see at a major league ball park.
Brand: Snapper B&S YT400
Year: 2011-2013 Model: YT400 Item Number: 2691030 Manufacture: B&S Engine Brand: B&S Pro HP: 26 Deck: 52 Transmission: K57 Speed: 5.8 Street Price: 5499 MSRP: 5999 Where To Buy: See you local dealer My Review: I have not written a stand alone review of this tractor yet. My Opinion: About the only difference between this garden tractor and the Simplicity Conquest is the Snapper has deck wheels that regulate the mowing height and the Simplicity uses a full length rear roller.
Brand: John Deere
John Deere X534
Year: 2011-2013 Model: X500 X530 X534 X540 Item Number: Multi-Terrain Tractor Manufacture: John Deere Engine Brand: John Deere iTorque HP: 23-24 Deck: 48-54 Transmission: Automatic with differential lock Speed: 7.2 Street Price: MSRP: 5899 – 7799 Where To Buy: Dealer Locator My Review: I have not written a stand alone review of this tractor yet. My Opinion: Many of you will want to compare the X300 series to the rest of this group because the price is comparable to the Simplicity Conquest but the X300 is not designed for heavy-duty ground engaging work.
The X500 is the best Garden Tractor on the market. Yes, it is the most expensive and costs more than twice as much as the best value Craftsman G5500. But if you want the most versitile, the best hill climbing, best ground engaging garden tractor it is worth spending the extra money. There are 4 models in this series. Starting with the basic X500, the 2 wheel steer X534 to the high-end X540 with power steering. I’m not going to go into all the features that make this the best mower. Just Google X500 John Deere review and you can read many honest reviews of this John Deere Garden Tractor.