The Best Lawn, Yard & Garden Tractor Buying Guide 2017 – How To Pick The Best For You!

The Best Lawn, Yard & Garden Tractor Buyer’s Guide 2017 – How To Pick The Best For You!

Lawn, Yard & Garden Tractor Buyer’s Guide Introduction

This guide will help you begin to sort through the differences for the 200 plus Lawn, Yard & Garden Tractors on the market. This guide will help you decide the best brand and model for you.

Lawn, Yard & Garden Tractors are designed to cut grass and pull attachments. In addition some of them are designed to clear snow. So, this guide is going to help you decide on the type of tractor you need based on the size of deck and the attachments you want to use.

Looking for a zero-turn? Check out this guide: The Best Zero Turn Mower Buyer’s Guide 

Note: Lawn & Garden tractors are designed to mow lawns. They are designed to mow weekly or bi-weekly growth. They cut no taller than 4 inches. They are NOT designed to mow pastures, timber, fields and paddocks. They are NOT designed to mow grass/weeds 12 inches to 6 feet tall. Mowing grass over 12 inches will damage deck spindles, belts, tires and bearings on all the models.

Pastures, fields, paddocks and timber require a rotary cutter or rough cut mower. Yes, I know your neighbor uses his but please don’t blame the mower or the brand when your mower requires $500 worth of repairs because you mowed your horse pasture. I highly recommend the AcrEase Rough Cut.

What Size Mower Deck Do You Need?

  1. Use the chart below to give you an idea of what size works well for your lawn. I do suggest going with a smaller deck if you want the best cut possible with your lawn tractor. Bigger is not always better when figuring out what size deck you can use on your yard.  Decks over 48 inches will cut larger areas quicker but they don’t cut as evenly from side to side as a 42 or 46 inch deck.
  2. Go around your yard and measure between landscape features like trees landscape beds and buildings. The smallest deck on a lawn tractor is now 42 inches (48 inches with discharge) so areas narrower than that will have to be mowed with a push mower or string trimmer.
  3. Slopes steeper than 15 degrees will have to be mowed with a walk behind or string trimmer. No, locking differential on your new Garden Tractor will not allow you to mow steeper slopes. It will help with snow plowing a lot though.
  4. If you have plenty of room to mow I now suggest a 46 inch deck for 1 acre yards. Today’s 46 inch decks all cut very well.
  • 1/2 acre or less = 30-42″ Deck
  • Up to 1 Acre = 38-42” Deck
  • 1-2 Acres = 42-48” Deck
  • 2+ Acres = 48-60″ Deck
  • 72 inch?  I don’t really suggest a 72 inch deck unless you have a large relatively flat area or you are mounting the deck under a compact tractor.

Bag, Mulch, or Side Discharge?

All of the current mowers I list are designed to throw the grass out the side (side discharge) and many will also mulch or bag with optional attachments.

Mulching uses special blades that chop up your grass clippings into small particles and a cover that plugs the discharge chute so those clippings are forced back into your turf. Mulching with a lawn tractor is more of an art than a science and not all lawn tractors mulch well. Even if the tractor mulches well weather conditions may make mulching impractical. To mulch well you need to cut at least 3 inches grass height, cut no more than 2 inches off at a time and mow when the grass is dry. Mulching Kits are designed for the specific brand and deck size. They are not interchangeable from one brand to another.

Bagger

2-Bin Bagger

Bagging consists of a tube connected to the side discharge and a set of bags that hang on the back of the tractor. The mower’s blades throw the grass clippings out through the tube and into the bags. Baggers work well for dry grass and leaves. They don’t work well when the grass is wet from rain or dew. Baggers come in either two or three bin styles – depending on the size of the tractor. Baggers are built specifically for a certain brand and can’t be interchanged from one brand to another.

So Which One Is Best For You? I will go through the different quality levels in the next sections. Sizing the deck is at the end of the article.

Lawn Tractors less than $1500 (economy)

Troy-Bilt Pony

Troy-Bilt Pony Lawn Tractor

If you no longer want to use a walk-behind to mow your yard a lawn tractor is a good choice. There are riding lawn mowers that cost less than $1500 and will mow your lawn faster than using a walk behind mower. They will also pull a small yard cart, lawn sweeper, dethatcher or tooth aerator. Most can be equipped with a bagger for collecting leaves and a few also have an available mulch kit. If you’re primarily looking just to cut grass and perform light clean up around the yard, a lawn tractor is a good choice. These mowers typically have low quality tires, large steering radius, and only come in a 42 or 46 inch deck size. The economy engines are typically internal splash lubricated and not designed to mow on slopes.

If an economy lawn tractor is the right choice for you go here: 2017 Lawn Tractors less than $1500

Lawn & Yard Tractors above $1500 (mid-grade)

Craftsman Yard Tractor

Craftsman Yard Tractor

Yard tractors are built to last longer than the under $1500 lawn tractors and have a few more features so you can get you work done faster. They generally have better cutting decks, better tires, better engines, better transmissions and a few steer almost a tightly as a zero turn. The better engines allow you to mow on slopes up to 15 degrees. You can attach a snow blade or snow blower to many of these models. Yard tractors cost between $1500 and $2500 depending on the size of the deck, the engine quality and the extra features. All the brands have models in this price and quality range but not all brands call them Yard Tractors. If properly maintained these tractors will last 10-15 years.

John Deere also makes the dealer only X300 series Lawn Tractors. These are outside the scope of this article and cost from $2999 to over $6000. Consumer Reports has an article that explains the differences here: Nothing runs like a Deere you buy at the dealer

If a lawn & yard tractor is the right choice for you go here: 2017 Lawn Tractors over $1500

Garden Tractors above $2600 (ground-engaging)

Cub Cadet Garden Tractor

Cub Cadet Garden Tractor

If you also want to use your tractor for pulling a self-powered roto-tiller, spike aerator, driveway leveler or cultivator a garden tractor is the right choice. Garden tractors have a heavy-duty transmission that is designed for ground engaging tasks.

Garden tractors also have heavy-duty frames and typically come in a 54 inch deck size (Craftsman and Cub Cadet have a 50 inch model. Husqvarna has a 48 inch model) They generally have a larger snow blade and snow blower attachments available. You can attach a snow blade or snow blower to most of these models. Garden tractors cost between $2700 and $3999 depending on the size of the deck, the engine quality and the extra features like power steering.

John Deere does not make a Garden Tractor but their dealer only X500 series have features and transmissions that are similar.

If a garden tractor is the right choice for you go here: 2017 Lawn & Garden Tractors over $1500

Light Garden Tractors $1900-$2500 (LGT)

Husqvarna LGT2654

Husqvarna LGT2654

There is one type of tractor that I want to caution you about. If you just look at the tractor, it looks like a Garden Tractor. It has large 23-24 inch wheels, a big seat and 22 -25 HP. In reality it is not a true garden tractor. It does not have the heavy duty transmission needed for ground-engaging work. If the price is less than $2500 it is too good to be true. If the price is less than $2500 DO NOT believe the “kid” trying to sell it to you that it’s a Garden Tractor. It is NOT a garden tractor! Craftsman, Husqvarna, John Deere, Columbia, Poulan Pro and Troy-bilt all make a model like this.

Massey Sub-Compact

If you want to use a bucket loader, use a PTO driven attachment in the rear, pull a manure spreader out in the field or use a belly mounted gear driven mower deck lawn & garden tractors will not work. You will need to look at a sub-compact or compact tractor for those chores. Sub-Compacts start around $10,000 and a typical unit with a mowing deck, bucket loader and one or two other attachments will cost you $25,000 or more.

Tractors over $4000

Lawn Tractors over $4000 is beyond the scope of this article.  This includes the John Deere 300, 500, 700 series lawn tractors and the Simplicity Broadmoor, Conquest, and Prestige. Please see your local John Deere or Simplicity dealer for details about these models.

324 Comments

  1. WK November 29, 2019
    • Paul November 29, 2019
  2. Jeff Northway November 22, 2019
    • Paul November 22, 2019
  3. Ken August 22, 2019
    • Paul August 23, 2019
  4. Susannah Wood June 10, 2019
    • Paul June 11, 2019
  5. Steve Poad May 20, 2019
    • Paul May 21, 2019
  6. Bill May 2, 2019
    • Paul May 3, 2019
  7. Den Hunter December 31, 2018
  8. Louise November 29, 2018
    • Paul December 4, 2018
  9. Matt October 11, 2018
    • Paul October 11, 2018
      • Matt October 13, 2018
        • Paul October 13, 2018
  10. WannaMow September 5, 2018
    • Paul September 5, 2018
      • WannaMow September 5, 2018
        • Paul September 5, 2018
  11. Shaheen Eydgahi September 2, 2018
  12. Aaron August 31, 2018
    • Paul September 2, 2018
  13. Mark August 27, 2018
    • Paul August 28, 2018
      • Mark August 28, 2018
        • Paul August 29, 2018
          • Mark August 29, 2018
  14. Paul May 12, 2018
    • Steve Bernhardt May 14, 2018
      • Paul May 14, 2018
  15. Steve Bernhardt May 11, 2018
  16. Miller May 2, 2018
    • Paul May 3, 2018
  17. Paul April 29, 2018
    • Brian May 3, 2018
      • Paul May 4, 2018
        • Brian May 7, 2018
          • Paul May 9, 2018
  18. susan April 24, 2018
  19. Paul April 17, 2018
    • Jay D April 17, 2018
      • Paul April 18, 2018
        • Jay D April 18, 2018
          • Paul April 19, 2018
  20. Jay D April 15, 2018
  21. Adam April 12, 2018
    • Paul April 13, 2018
      • Adam April 13, 2018
  22. Paul April 12, 2018
    • Brian April 13, 2018
      • Paul April 14, 2018
      • Brian April 14, 2018
        • Paul April 15, 2018
          • Brian April 25, 2018
            • Paul April 26, 2018
              • Brian April 26, 2018
                • Paul April 27, 2018
                  • Brian April 27, 2018
                    • Paul April 27, 2018
                    • Brian April 28, 2018
  23. Brian April 11, 2018
    • Paul April 12, 2018
      • Brian April 12, 2018
  24. Ken April 10, 2018
    • Paul April 11, 2018
      • Ken April 11, 2018
        • Paul April 12, 2018
  25. Dan April 8, 2018
    • Paul April 11, 2018
  26. Paul March 21, 2018
  27. Alan March 21, 2018
    • Paul March 21, 2018
      • Alan March 21, 2018
  28. Antonio March 20, 2018
    • Paul March 20, 2018
  29. Alan March 7, 2018
    • Paul March 7, 2018
  30. Chan March 2, 2018
    • Paul March 6, 2018
      • Chan March 6, 2018
        • Paul March 7, 2018
          • Chan March 13, 2018
            • Paul March 14, 2018
              • Chan March 15, 2018
                • Paul March 15, 2018
                  • Chan March 24, 2018
                    • Paul March 25, 2018
                    • Chan March 25, 2018
  31. Jason March 2, 2018
    • Paul March 6, 2018
  32. Jeff thraen February 27, 2018
    • Paul March 2, 2018
  33. Jeff February 18, 2018
    • Paul February 19, 2018
      • Jeff February 19, 2018
        • Paul February 19, 2018
  34. Stephen December 11, 2017
    • Paul December 11, 2017
  35. Brian December 8, 2017
    • Paul December 11, 2017
      • Brian December 11, 2017
        • Paul December 11, 2017
          • Brian December 12, 2017
            • Paul December 13, 2017
          • Brian December 13, 2017
            • Paul December 14, 2017
              • Brian December 14, 2017
                • Paul December 14, 2017
                  • Brian December 15, 2017
                    • Paul December 16, 2017
  36. Bob Schmidt September 21, 2017
    • Paul September 21, 2017
  37. Joel September 19, 2017
    • Paul September 19, 2017
  38. Larry Moss September 16, 2017
    • Paul September 16, 2017
      • Larry Moss September 17, 2017
        • Paul September 17, 2017
  39. Bill Thoma July 26, 2017
    • Paul July 26, 2017
  40. Daniel Bentrup July 23, 2017
    • Paul July 24, 2017
      • Bob Schmidt July 24, 2017
        • Paul July 26, 2017
          • Bob Schmidt August 5, 2017
            • Paul August 5, 2017
  41. Greg Tinkler July 7, 2017
    • Paul July 7, 2017
      • Greg Tinkler July 7, 2017
      • Greg Tinkler July 8, 2017
        • Rudedawg November 14, 2017
          • Paul November 16, 2017
  42. Duramax July 6, 2017
    • Paul July 6, 2017
      • Duramax July 6, 2017
  43. Bryan July 4, 2017
    • Paul July 6, 2017
  44. Larry Lipscomb June 15, 2017
    • Paul June 17, 2017
      • Larry Lipscomb June 17, 2017
  45. Gray June 12, 2017
    • Paul June 14, 2017
      • Gray June 14, 2017
  46. Marc Hemmerick June 3, 2017
    • marc hemmerick June 8, 2017
      • Paul June 8, 2017
  47. Jim May 19, 2017
    • Paul May 20, 2017
      • Jim May 20, 2017
  48. Jay May 19, 2017
    • Paul May 19, 2017
      • Jay May 19, 2017
        • Paul May 19, 2017
  49. Randy May 19, 2017
    • Paul May 19, 2017
      • Randy May 19, 2017
        • Paul May 19, 2017
          • Randy May 20, 2017
            • Paul May 20, 2017
  50. Jay May 16, 2017
    • Jay May 16, 2017
      • Paul May 16, 2017
    • Paul May 16, 2017
      • Jay May 16, 2017
        • Paul May 16, 2017
          • Jay May 16, 2017
    • Jay May 16, 2017
      • Paul May 17, 2017
  51. Sonja May 16, 2017
    • Paul May 16, 2017
      • Sonja May 16, 2017
        • Sonja May 16, 2017
          • Paul May 16, 2017
          • Sonja May 17, 2017
            • Paul May 17, 2017
          • Sonja May 17, 2017
  52. Pete S May 13, 2017
    • Paul May 14, 2017
      • Pete S May 14, 2017
  53. Chris R May 9, 2017
    • Paul May 9, 2017
      • Chris R May 10, 2017
        • Paul May 10, 2017
    • Scott R Miller May 10, 2017
      • Paul May 10, 2017
        • Scott R Miller May 10, 2017
  54. Barbie May 8, 2017
    • Paul May 9, 2017
      • Barbie May 9, 2017
      • Barbie May 10, 2017
        • Paul May 12, 2017
          • Barbie May 12, 2017
            • Paul May 12, 2017
  55. Bill Chriswell May 7, 2017
    • Bill Chriswell May 7, 2017
  56. Zach May 4, 2017
    • Paul May 6, 2017
  57. Andrew April 24, 2017
    • Paul April 25, 2017
      • Andrew April 25, 2017
        • Paul April 25, 2017
        • Bob April 25, 2017
          • Andrew April 26, 2017
  58. Tim Hildebrandt Campbellsport, Wisc. April 24, 2017
    • Paul April 25, 2017
  59. Brett April 18, 2017
    • Paul April 19, 2017
  60. Mike April 17, 2017
  61. Greg Tinkler April 16, 2017
    • Paul April 17, 2017
      • Greg Tinkler April 17, 2017
  62. Sonja April 16, 2017
    • Sonja April 19, 2017
      • Paul April 19, 2017
  63. Brian April 15, 2017
    • Paul April 15, 2017
      • Brian April 15, 2017
        • Paul April 16, 2017
  64. andrew chan April 14, 2017
    • Paul April 14, 2017
      • andrew chan April 15, 2017
        • Paul April 15, 2017
      • andrew chan April 30, 2017
        • Paul April 30, 2017
  65. Marc April 12, 2017
    • Paul April 12, 2017
  66. Bob April 3, 2017
    • Paul April 3, 2017
  67. Johnna King April 3, 2017
    • Paul April 3, 2017
  68. Greg Bardsley April 2, 2017
    • Paul April 2, 2017
  69. Craftsman guy April 1, 2017
    • Paul April 1, 2017
  70. Kumar March 31, 2017
    • Paul April 3, 2017
  71. Jarrett March 31, 2017
    • Paul April 3, 2017
      • Jarrett April 3, 2017
  72. Paul March 30, 2017
    • Paul March 30, 2017
  73. Bob Schmidt March 29, 2017
    • Paul March 29, 2017
  74. Matt March 28, 2017
    • Paul March 28, 2017
  75. Dan March 22, 2017
    • Paul March 22, 2017
  76. Mike Holbrooks March 22, 2017
    • Paul March 22, 2017
      • Mike Holbrooks March 22, 2017
  77. Paul March 22, 2017
    • Phil March 22, 2017
      • Paul March 22, 2017
        • Phil March 23, 2017
          • Paul March 23, 2017
  78. Phil Wilson March 22, 2017
  79. Bob Schmidt March 18, 2017
    • Paul March 19, 2017
  80. Gary Tillotson March 15, 2017
  81. Bob Schmidt March 14, 2017
    • <